A new study published in the journal Frontiers in Marine Science analyzes and interprets sediment cores extracted from the northern South China Sea in 2016. Caleb Pittman of Tech Times provides a nice, detailed summary of the study. The data reveals that the most prominent signal is not monsoons as one would expect but dam and reservoir construction. China launched a dam and reservoir building boom after 1950 that “has overridden the monsoon's 200-year hold on the record, producing a proxy decoupling that calls the reliability of single-proxy paleoclimate studies from this region into question.” That decoupling produced a dual signal: a decline in sediment coming in from rivers sediment and the coarsening of grain sizes. These happened simultaneously due to dams and reservoirs holding back sediment.
The researchers looked at
kaolinite concentrations. Kaolinite is a clay mineral that forms in warm, humid
conditions. In this region, it has been associated with stronger East Asian
Summer Monsoons (EASMs). The sediment record from 1850 to around 1920 reflects
strong monsoons and abundant kaolinite. Before that, there was less kaolinite
and along with other indicators, it shows weaker monsoons. During the 1850-1920
period, the kaolinite/(illite + chlorite) ratio and the titanium-to-calcium
(Ti/Ca) ratio both rose with intensifying EASMs. Higher Ti/Ca
ratios are associated with higher amounts of terrigenous (continent-derived)
sediment. Smectite, another clay mineral is associated with stronger winter
monsoons and is sourced from Luzon Island in the Philippines, carried northward
by the Kuroshio Current. The smectite is derived from weathering of volcanic
rocks in alkaline conditions. Coral records and tree-rings support that
conclusion.
After 1950 the EASM weakened
and this is well-documented. This should result in finer sediment reaching the
continental shelf at lower rates. However, instead of the expected finer
sediment, the record shows coarser sediment. They refer to this as proxy decoupling
from the climate signals. The decoupling was likely caused by China’s extensive
dam building projects across its major river systems beginning at that time.
“Hydrological and meteorological station data confirm
that sediment discharge from these rivers fell dramatically between the 1950s
and the 2010s, primarily because reservoirs trap the fine-grained particles
that would otherwise reach the coast.”
This is a well-known effect
of dam construction. In this area sediment supply to the shelf dropped by about
70%. I was initially a bit baffled by the increase in coarse-grained sediment
but the explanation is given below:
“When a dam intercepts fine-grained sediment in its
reservoir, the downstream channel begins eroding its own bed — preferentially
removing fine particles (silt and clay) that are easier to resuspend and
transport. The material that eventually reaches the coastal shelf is therefore
relatively enriched in coarser fractions. This is the mechanism that reconciles
the paradox: less total terrigenous material reaching the shelf (falling Ti/Ca)
but coarser grain sizes in what does arrive. It is not a contradiction. It is
the signature of sediment starvation combined with selective fine-particle
depletion.”
The change was confirmed as a
wider regional effect with another core of sedimentation collected in the
Taiwan Strait, derived from a different set of rivers, including the Yangtze
and from rivers in Taiwan. The decrease in kaolinite alone could have been
attributed to stronger or less variable EASMs. The coarsening grain sizes,
however, point to dam construction.
The sediment-starved
continental shelf has serious implications. These include increased coastal
erosion, which is another common effect of dam construction, and much more:
“The northern South China Sea is among the most
biologically productive marginal seas in the world, and its benthic
communities, fisheries, and shallow-water reef systems depend on a balanced
sediment budget. When rivers deliver less fine-grained material to the shelf,
the chemistry, texture, and fertility of seafloor sediments change — affecting
the organisms that live in and on them. The broader literature on dam-driven
sediment starvation documents many deltas shifting to net erosion as sediment
supply fell.”
The clay mineral fractions
and grain-size proxies also reveal sediment source region differences due to
climatic differences, mainly higher kaolinite fractions in warm and humid South
China regions, in contrast to sediments derived from cooler northern rivers
such as the Yangtze.
“The clay mineral assemblages in the two cores encode
the geographic fingerprints of their respective source regions. In Core D0,
kaolinite dominates the terrigenous fraction — consistent with a Pearl River
source, where warm, humid South China weathering produces kaolinite at average
proportions of around 47 percent in river sediments. In Core Y22, illite and
chlorite are more abundant — consistent with Yangtze River basin and Taiwan
mountain river sources, where colder, more physically erosive conditions and
tectonic uplift produce physically weathered clay minerals rather than
chemically weathered kaolinite.”
References:
South
China Sea seafloor records dams, not monsoons: Study decodes 250-year signal. Caleb
Pittmann. Tech Times. August 26, 2026. South
China Sea seafloor records dams, not monsoons: Study decodes 250-year signal
Climate
and anthropogenic controls on sediment dynamics in the Northern South China Sea
and Taiwan Strait over the last 250 years. Qiong Wu, Shaohua Zhao, Chao Cao,
and Hong Peng. Frontiers in Marine Science, Marine Biogeochemistry. Volume 13.
August 25, 2026. Frontiers
| Climate and anthropogenic controls on sediment dynamics in the Northern South
China Sea and Taiwan Strait over the last 250 years






No comments:
Post a Comment