Robert Bryce is
known for telling it like it is. This case is no different, and I agree
completely. Constitutional press freedom simply requires Trump to tolerate
negative news stories. He may not like it, but that is the way it is. No judge
or court should allow him to ban press coverage.
In this case, Bryce simply states
the wording James Madison used when he introduced the amendment:
“The people shall not be deprived or abridged of their
right to speak, to write, or to publish their sentiments; and the freedom of
the press, as one of the great bulwarks of liberty, shall be inviolable.”
As we know, Trump has done other
things that may be illegal or unconstitutional, and he often treads on that
line between legal and illegal every opportunity he gets. If he doesn’t like it
here, he should leave, because that is the way it is. He does not get to make
up the rules. That is not how our government works as much as he would like it
to be.
Fortunately, the ban was struck
down by a judge, and one that Trump appointed, at that.
Bryce continued, regarding the
quote:
“That sentence, written by a man who’s often called the
“Father of the Constitution,” provides essential context for President Trump’s
move last week to bar CNN, MS NOW, and Politico from the White House. And to
add more foolishness to an already indefensible move, on Friday, while in the
Oval Office, Trump went even further, saying, “It’s sick. I mean there’s
something wrong with a country that can allow people to write purposely
negative stories.”
“Excuse my language, but WTF?”
I think it is likely that Trump
simply doesn’t understand how he is limited by the Constitution, but ignorance
is no excuse. If he did, he would not have enacted the ban or uttered the
sentence about negative stories.
Below, he summarizes the potential
implications of Trump adding this blunder to his sinking approval ratings. He
notes Trump is also damaging the GOP. I would add that the lack of or
lackluster pushback by the GOP against Trump’s blunders damages them just as
badly. I won’t even consider voting for a Republican until he is long gone.
“Trump’s ban of the media outlets and his mocking of the
First Amendment are beyond the pale. They are a strategic blunder, an own goal.
And Trump is scoring that own goal at the very moment his approval ratings are
the lowest of his political career. A poll released on Monday showed his
approval rating is just 32%. That’s the lowest approval rating for a sitting
president in the last nine midterms. Further, Trump’s doing more damage to the
Republican Party’s brand, and he’s doing it just six weeks before the pivotal
midterm elections.”
Trump later tried to invoke National Security to support the ban, something that has worked with him in the past to bypass Congress and the courts. It won't work this time.
References:
Trump
v. Madison (And Streisand). Robert Bryce. Substack. September 22, 2026.
Trump
v. Madison (And Streisand) - Robert Bryce

















