Blog Archive

Monday, November 16, 2026

Subnational Industrial Strategy in the Electro-Industrial Era, by RMI: Summary, Review, and Commentary


     This report explores trends and strategies for dealing with power demand and expanding industrialization. The authors refer to the “electro-industrial era,” where “growth and national security depend on an increasingly interconnected system of electrified technologies and supply chains.” RMI’s economic development team partnered with the New Energy Industrial Strategy (NEIS) Center to develop the framework outlined in this report. The report emphasizes that “state and local tax credits and project-level investment incentives play an important role in mobilizing private capital, catalyzing job and cluster growth, and enabling electricity capacity expansion.”

     The authors note that the technologies powering this electro-industrial era share three features: efficiency (due to avoiding combustion), scalability, and digitalization capacity (software upgrades can improve hardware capabilities). As the table below indicates, there are examples of these, such as the high efficiency of thermal energy storage, and another one that I think might be cool – digitally upgradable heat pumps.




     Below, they show how clean energy and electrification technologies have dropped dramatically in price. While that is impressive, they are still not competitive with fossil fuels, especially when integration and delivery costs are included. The second graph shows lithium-ion cost drops and demand along with projections. Those projections suggest that lithium-ion cost drops are pretty much maxed out.






     The graph below shows Mainland China’s utter dominance in most of these technologies, their supply chains, components, and resources. That graph alone should give some pause for an all-in electrification push since China has already shown a willingness to restrict supplies of critical minerals and components and has implemented export controls, which would compromise U.S. energy security.




     The U.S. has responded by increasing the development of domestic critical minerals mining and processing and associated supply chains, but this will take time, likely decades. The graph below shows U.S. investment towards alleviating the supply chain risks, with most just beginning in the early 2020s. They also note that the U.S. is set to capture only a “puny” share of the growing new energy export market worldwide.

     The next graph is interesting. It shows the projected selected global drivers of electricity demand growth to 2050. These are all existing technologies that will grow in deployment.




     The report then delves into regional electricity demand growth due to subnational policy changes, mainly by states. They see an abundance of demand growth in the Southeastern region. However, their graphs are based on capacity additions, which makes them hugely misleading, as usual.

     The flow chart below shows an idealized scenario where all technology and policy work together to accelerate project development. It includes faster and more predictable permitting, which will likely happen if the more Progressive Dems are not able to block BAAJA permit reform.




     The map below is interesting. It shows a county-level map of projects that could be considered electro-industrial. They note the emergence of a region where battery projects are proliferating in the Great Lakes and Midwest, which they are calling a battery belt; the prevalence of solar, wind, and battery projects in Texas; semiconductor project development in Arizona’s Maricopa County; and lithium supply and processing development in Nevada, which hosts the largest U.S. lithium mine and associated supply chains. They suggest that these clusters make other projects more likely to be developed in them due to the synergies, which makes other areas less likely to host them.




     Below, they display what they call a GREASE policy framework for subnational industrial policy. GREASE is an acronym for “governance, regional targeting, expansive ambition, accountability, sector strategies, and environmental co-benefits.” They note four areas where state and local policies can be effective: market development, private capital mobilization, site readiness, and workforce development.




     The map below shows where economic benefits will result from favorable state incentives. Here, it can be seen that the Great Lakes and Southeast regions stand to benefit most from state and local electro-industrial incentives.




     It should be noted that projects with low profitability or long-term payback of investments often require significant incentives just to stay above water. Some projects that may be in the public interest are simply not very profitable or not profitable at all. Thus, those types of projects are simply not likely to proliferate under any scenario but may merely add a little bit to satisfying demand. Overcoming economic barriers through incentives alone is not broadly feasible. I think we need to be careful, as overbuilding clean energy and clean industry too fast has the very real risk of raising power costs for consumers, a sensitive issue. Unfortunately, most of their policy recommendations are based mainly on increasing incentives and subsidies, something the Trump administration has gutted. It is likely that, with a new Democratically controlled Congress, many of these incentives can return, and I agree that they should. Even after they return, issues with profitability will remain for many technologies.

     Most of the following questions can be answered, in my opinion, by proceeding cautiously and slowly and avoiding projects with the worst economics. We don’t want to pay high costs for projects with little economic benefit. Therefore, I don’t think it would be wise to seek to vastly accelerate the deployment of these technologies before they are market-ready and at least somewhat competitive at typical incentive levels.




References:

 

Subnational Industrial Strategy in the Electro-Industrial Era: How states and regions can win durable investment, jobs, and leadership in new energy. Aaron Brickman, Ben Feshbach, and Hannah Perkins. RMI. September 4, 2026. Subnational Industrial Strategy in the Electro-Industrial Era - RMI

Aridity is a Driver of Riverine Nitrogen Pollution, In Addition to Human Activities Such as Agriculture and Sewage Runoff


      While it is well-known that human endeavors, particularly those leading to agricultural and sewage runoff and combustion, lead to nitrogen pollution via nitrates, there are also natural sources. A new paper published in Science shows that riverine nitrogen pollution is also a natural feature in arid climates. The results and revelations surprised the researchers from Penn State University, who led the study. Headwaters in dry regions that only flow seasonally were found to have the highest readings and are thought to be due to long-term buildup over years, as it is not washed out enough through precipitation events.

     According to Science Alert:

“To study this common contaminant, researchers compiled nitrate readings from 7000 locations along rivers, as well as data on the local climate, land use, and soil condition. They then trained machine learning models to predict nitrate concentrations based on environmental factors and applied them to 2.9 million river sections worldwide.”




     They note that about 480 million people worldwide live in proximity to rivers where nitrate concentrations exceed levels that can potentially lead to negative health effects.

     According to Penn State:

“Nitrate is one of the most prevalent forms of inorganic pollution found in rivers, streams, lakes and groundwater worldwide, with about 18% of the U.S. population exposed to drinking water with elevated nitrate levels between 2021 and 2023. In addition to harming ecosystems, high levels of nitrate in drinking water can lead to a host of health conditions…”

     The U.S. “Corn Belt” in the Midwest shows the highest nitrate concentrations in the world, and it is considered a major pollutant there and is responsible as well for harmful algae blooms.

“For nitrate, we have a regulatory standard set at 10 milligrams of nitrate per liter of water, primarily to prevent acute diseases like blue baby syndrome,” Sadayappan said. “This has been the standard since the 1970s, but scientists are now observing that slower, chronic conditions like cancers or issues related to reproduction can be linked to exposure at much lower levels, like 2.5 milligrams of nitrate per liter of water.”

     The researchers did emphasize limitations of the study, where the bulk of the data comes from temperate climates where water quality data is available. The machine learning was geared toward filling in the global gaps in that data to give a global model.  

“The Sahara Desert in northern Africa, one of the most arid, remote locations on Earth, displayed comparable if not higher nitrate concentrations than humid locations, like southeast Asia, even if those humid environments had extensive urban or agricultural development. According to Li, the best explanation is that naturally occurring nitrate builds up in arid climates over years, since limited water movement prevents it from being washed out.”




References:

 

Climate aridity amplifies global riverine nitrate beyond human inputs. Kayalvizhi Sadayappan and Li Li. Science. 12 Nov 2026. Vol 394, Issue 6825. pp. 773-778. Climate aridity amplifies global riverine nitrate beyond human inputs | Science

Humans aren’t the only nitrate polluter. Science Advisor. November 16, 2026.

Nitrate pollution in rivers linked to dry climates, not just human activity. Ty Tkacik. Penn State University. November 12, 2026. Nitrate pollution in rivers linked to dry climates, not just human activity | Penn State University

 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

The Right to Publicly Criticize One’s Government or Its Actions Should Be Regarded as a Fundamental Human Right, as Should Be the Right to Criticize Any Religion: Opinion


      I am fortunate to live in a country where any citizen can openly criticize the government or its actions. Places and situations where one cannot do that include both political and religious prohibitions that cross over into human rights denial. Basic human rights should be emphasized as paramount, as trumping other concerns. Countries that are democracies offer, by far, the best protections of human rights.

     There are obvious situations where rights to criticize governments have been revoked and criminalized. Russia did it after it invaded Ukraine, handing out prison terms, some lengthy, for those who criticize the Kremlin’s war. Iran imprisons those who criticize its government and sometimes executes political prisoners as treasonous collaborators with its enemies in obviously sham trials. People tend to leave those countries if they can, becoming defectors. They often don’t mind that since they would prefer detractors not to live among them. North Korea goes so far as to threaten the families of those who may be captured fighting against Ukraine or to execute people, even children, simply for watching South Korean TV shows or movies. China imprisons people for speaking out against the communist party. Authoritarians control behavior with harsh threats. That is their MO. These four countries have totalitarian governments. Iran may change its president and parliament members, but its government is still quite totalitarian. Other countries can also be seen as totalitarian. These include the Gulf State monarchies and other countries that limit and suppress opposition parties. Islamic countries, in general, have limited freedom of speech, some more or less than others. Marxist Latin American countries have been associated with human rights abuses. These include Venezuela, Cuba, Bolivia, and Nicaragua, although Bolivia now has a better, non-socialist government.

     Oddly, in France and some other countries in Europe, where recent protests have been intense, sometimes involving violence, and with abundant vandalism and arson, it is the Islamists and far-left Marxists who have been a feature of the protests, though many others are involved as well. In essence, they are exercising their rights as citizens of democratic countries. Their rights do not extend to the right to commit crimes. The far-left parties are the parties that use protest as a means most often in democratic countries. They are also the protestors most likely to become violent. They are basically abusing the freedom of speech by taking it too far and mixing it with destructive and sometimes violent actions. It’s odd that Islamists would boldly protest against democratic governments when the governments of the countries they came from would not allow it at all. While it is fine that they protest if they are non-violent, they should perhaps be content to live in a country that has basic human rights.

     In Gaza there was never such freedom to criticize the government, or rather Hamas. I read a story recently that journalists in Gaza would routinely suppress stories where some citizens were speaking out against Hamas policies out of fear of reprisal. That certainly indicates no freedom of the press in a place where there is also no real freedom of speech. Any anti-Hamas groups that appeared were routinely killed by Hamas. It should not be forgotten that Gaza’s government is also a widely recognized terrorist organization that to this day refuses to disarm, still seeks to import weapons and re-militarize, and is still recruiting members, despite the literal destruction of much of their country. Fanatics have strong beliefs and dedication. They are aided by the propaganda spewed by anti-Zionists around the world in many ways. We hear much about the suffering of the Palestinian people, the same people who celebrated 911, who thrashed the Israeli captives as they were brought to Gaza in October 2023, and many who kept those people confined in miserable conditions where they were tortured physically and psychologically. Of course, there are Palestinian people in Gaza who really want no part of Hamas. However, even those people are trapped out of fear of criticizing them and have been indoctrinated by Hamas propaganda, including from the UN schools that help to spread it. That the UN was heavily infiltrated by the world’s best-known terrorist organization is a stain on the UN’s credibility. Of course, it is not wrong to argue that Israel has been too heavy-handed and has killed many more civilians than necessary despite the extensive human shielding.

 


The Right to Criticize Religion: Islam is the Main Problem

     Religious blasphemy laws in some Islamic countries are long outdated and suppressive of basic human rights. Threatening to execute someone or actually doing it, which has happened, for crimes such as insulting the prophet is a human rights issue. Saudi Arabia recently threatened to execute a worker from Sri Lanka for the crime of insulting the Prophet. Egypt has done the same with a man who converted from Islam to Christianity. The fiancée of the man accused alleged that at least 180 other Christians are being held by the authorities on similarly dubious charges. The accusers often cite Sharia Law as the basis for the penalties. Sharia Law, which is based on Medieval interpretations of Islamic Law, is simply incompatible with basic human rights. The draconian laws against women and minorities in Pakistan and especially Afghanistan under Taliban rule are more examples of obvious human rights abuses. These countries need to get the fuck out of the Middle Ages and treat people fairly.

     Israel has been hailed as the only democracy in the Middle East. There, one can criticize both the government and the religions. I just heard on the radio yesterday an editor of the left-leaning Israeli media organization Haaretz strongly criticize the Netanyahu government. One can also criticize the religion-based views of the highly religious far-right Jews. Of course, Israel also has millions of Sunni Arabs, and they have representatives in the Israeli government in proportion to their share of the population. The governments of Lebanon and Iraq have power-sharing features where different religious sects, which include Christianity in Lebanon, are automatically represented. Of course, these are not democracies but have some features of democracies. One time in the 2000s, I was at an international festival in a university town and was looking at the flags of all the countries and by chance met the only two Afghan students at the university. They seemed to be nice guys and were proud to find their flag represented. We had a short discussion about religious freedom and though their words were guarded, they sort of conceded that people should be free to practice any religion they chose to practice, though they seemed a bit put off by my inquiries.

     There are other conflicts in the world where those who practice Islam are oppressed by those who don’t, such as the poor treatment of the Rohingya minority in Myanmar by the military government.

     There are also places where there is no freedom for any religion, such as in communist China, where Sinicization is what is offered to replace religion. According to an article in the New York Post:

“President Xi Jinping euphemistically defines Sinicization as “adapting religion to socialism with Chinese characteristics.” In practice it means pastors must ban all minors under 18 years old from church, center sermons on Xi Jinping’s Thought, and spy on their congregations, among many other demands and restrictions.”

     Protestant Christianity, the biggest religious movement in China, is the latest target of Sinicization. China also suppresses the religions of ethnic minorities such as the Uyghur Muslims and the Tibetan Buddhists, among others. China’s recently passed ethnic unity law is another farce with very thinly veiled racism as a feature.

“It is using lawfare in kangaroo courts against the Christians, not the brutal tactics that it applies to crush the Tibetan Buddhists, Uyghur Muslims, or Falun Gong practitioners. It is persecution nonetheless.”

     In conclusion, freedom of speech, freedom of the press, and freedom of religion all preserve the right to criticize any government or religion, and those rights are fundamental to a modern world that is fair, impartial, and civilized.

 


References:

 

They had him crucified: Christian convert faces torture, execution in Egypt for leaving Islam. Danielle Greyman-Kennard. The Jerusalem Times. November 9, 2026. They had him crucified: Christian convert faces torture, execution in Egypt for leaving Islam

Saudi Arabia has sentenced a foreign worker to death over a Facebook post. Why isn’t there a bigger outcry? The independent. Alisha Rahaman Sarkar. October 7, 2026. Saudi Arabia has sentenced a man to death over a Facebook post. Why isn’t there a bigger outcry? | The Independent

China unleashes a sweeping crackdown on Christians. Nina Shea. New York Post. November 15, 2026. China unleashes a sweeping crackdown on Christians

 

 

Saturday, November 14, 2026

Integrated Geophysical and Geotechnical Site Characterisation for Civil Infrastructure Development in Sekondi-Takoradi, Ghana: Scientific Paper Summary & Review


     This paper details a geotechnical site characterization for its applicability to accommodate heavy structural loads in Sekondi-Takoradi, Ghana. The goal of the investigation, according to the paper’s abstract, is as follows:

“The investigation focused on evaluating the engineering integrity, shear strength, and ultimate bearing capacity of the foundation soils to support heavy structural loads. Additionally, the study aimed to delineate critical subsurface anomalies, weak zones, and adverse geological structures that could compromise structural stability or threaten foundation longevity.”

     Basic site characteristics are shown below.











     The investigation also relied on geophysical surveys, including resistivity imaging and acoustic surveys. The investigation also revealed, “weak lateritic soils often associated with seepage paths that are recognised as near-surface fractures or joints in the areas.” Those areas were found to have negative impacts on the load-bearing capacity of the subsurface.

     The proposed site was designated for the satellite faculty of SRID, Ghana, at Sofokrom (a suburb of Essikado). The site is in a tropical, coastal area with some topographic relief, not too far above sea level, but with hilly areas as well. Some of its characteristics are shown above.

     The geologic setting involves a crystalline basement overlain unconformably by a sedimentary rock sequence consisting of sandstones and shales.

“The sedimentary environment has been interpreted to be of non-marine to coastal marine facies. It was postulated that Paleoweathering in the source area, therefore, is one of the most important processes affecting the composition of sedimentary rocks.”

     The electrical resistivity imaging (ERI) survey involved employing a dipole-dipole array. These are typically used for subsurface thickness, rock structure, groundwater flow and aquifer, groundwater salinity investigations as well as in the oil & gas industry to determine formation water characteristics. The vertical electric sounding (VES) survey was used for subsurface lithologic characterization. VES was done before ERI and was conducted in different features of the terrain, such as hilly areas and depressions, as well as flat areas. A key goal was to identify weak zones where hydrologic seepage was prevalent so they could be avoided.

     Several pits were dug to 1.5 meters, and samples were collected and sent to the lab to determine geotechnical properties such as the Atterberg limits (liquid limit, plastic limit, and plasticity index), particle size distribution, and the direct shear strength. The liquid limit estimates the water content of fine-grained soils. The plastic limit estimates the moisture content of the soil below which it transforms from plastic to a semi-solid state. The plasticity index is “the range of moisture content at which the soil is plastic and is the difference between liquid limit and plastic limit values.” Particle size analysis was performed with standard sieve techniques. The sieved particles were used to determine the specific gravity of the samples. The direct shear test (DST) procedure was done in two test pits of the most common terrain on the site, the hilly terrain and the depressions. It is described below:

“In carrying out this test, a 60 mm × 60 mm cutting box was driven into the undisturbed sample from the trial pits that is forced into the experimental tube to obtain the sample for the test. The extracted sample was carefully put into the shear box to ensure that the ring fitted properly into the shear box apparatus. The gauge for the horizontal movement, vertical movement, and proving ring was adjusted to the zero (2500) mark. The beam jack was adjusted to be in contact with the lever-loading arm and the sample was subjected to the normal loads of 2.1 kg, 4.2 kg, and 8.5 kg. A shear force was then applied under each load and the shear stress was monitored until failure occurred. The sample was unloaded and weighed. The sample was later placed in the oven to dry and its dry weight was recorded. The procedure allows the displacement under shear load, the proving ring reading and settlement dial gauge to be recorded.”

     The derived soil profiles, shown below, showed “stiff, dry brown, loose, and shattered coarse-grained sand silt mixtures” for the top meter with some gravel in a few pits.





     The results of the Atterberg Limits revealed the site was favorable for heavy loads, as described below:

“The relatively low liquid limits and plasticity indices indicate soils with limited volume-change potential, thereby contributing to favourable subgrade performance under anticipated loading conditions. These consistency characteristics were considered together with the particle-size distribution and soil classification in evaluating the engineering suitability of the site.”

     The particle size distribution analysis revealed that the gravelly soils were the best substrate and the silty-sandy soils were rated as a fair substrate, as described below:

“Based on the AASHTO and USCS classification systems, soil samples from trial Pits 1, 2 and 3 are classified as A-2-6 (GC), indicating gravelly soils with clay fines that are generally considered good subgrade materials because of their relatively low plasticity, high gravel content and favourable engineering characteristics. In contrast, trial Pits 4 and 5 are classified as A-2-4 (GM), representing silty gravel soils that are considered fair subgrade materials owing to their comparatively higher sand content and lower cohesion. The engineering assessment of subgrade quality was therefore based on the combined interpretation of the USCS classification, AASHTO classification, particle-size distribution, plasticity characteristics and direct shear strength results rather than on a single engineering parameter.”

     The direct shear test results indicated competent substrate at some pits and less competent substrate at others, suggesting different foundation designs would be required for the less competent areas. A summary of the geotechnical and geophysical investigations is given below.

“In all, the integrated geophysical and geotechnical investigations indicate that the site is generally underlain by competent subsurface materials capable of supporting civil infrastructure. However, localized depressions, fractured zones and areas of elevated moisture content may adversely affect foundation performance. Accordingly, foundation selection should be site-specific, with shallow foundations being suitable in competent areas, while localized ground improvement or deeper foundation systems may be required within weaker zones identified by the integrated investigation.”






     Overall, the site was found to be competent for supporting the heavy loads anticipated in the project, with some foundation design amendments in less competent areas. Composite results of the investigation for each of the five pits are shown in the columns below.



Figure 30. Columnal presentation of the geo-parameters for the lithologic sequence in the study area.





References:

 

Integrated Geophysical and Geotechnical Site Characterisation for Civil Infrastructure Development in Sekondi-Takoradi, Ghana. Asare Asante-Annor, Ernest Nyamekye Addo, Kwaku Raymond Frimpong, and Gbenga Moses Olayanju. Open Journal of Geology. Vol.16 No.7, July 2026. Integrated Geophysical and Geotechnical Site Characterisation for Civil Infrastructure Development in Sekondi-Takoradi, Ghana

Friday, November 13, 2026

Anaerobic Digester Effluent Treatment and Reuse for the Food and Beverage Industry: Featuring ZwitterCo’s Superfiltration and Reverse Osmosis Systems


     ZwitterCo makes superfiltration (SF) and reverse osmosis (RO) systems to recover anaerobic digester effluent to reuse water for cooling, boilers, and clean-in-place (CIP), and return the solids to the digester. Their products are geared toward food and beverage plants that run an anaerobic digester. Below, they stress that their membranes are the key to the product’s success.

“Because the membranes resist the organic fouling that limits conventional membranes as feed quality changes, the system maintains its designed output with less cleaning, maintenance, and membrane replacement. Plants gain a reliable reuse water supply at a lower operating cost.”




     Below, they give the factors that drive treatment and water reuse. Surcharges on biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), total suspended solids (TSS), and fats, oils, and grease (FOG) give a reverse financial incentive to invest in treatment and reuse. Discharge limits and avoiding the fouling of equipment are additional incentives.




     As shown below, the company offers packaged modular systems and full or partial customized solutions for specific industry applications.




     The company offers on-site pilots and includes startup, commissioning, and remote monitoring of its systems.

 

 

References

 

Digester Effluent Treatment and Reuse for Food and Beverage Processing. ZwitterCo Systems. One Pager - ZwitterCo Systems - Digester Effluent Treatment and Reuse.pdf

Hydropower Generation Hit Record Lows in the U.S. Southwest, Including the Colorado River Basin, Due to Ongoing Drought: Recent Heavy El Niño Rains Have Helped Lift Reservoir Level


     According to the EIA, the ongoing drought in the U.S. Southwest has resulted in record-low hydropower output this past summer. This hydropower region includes Arizona, New Mexico, and small parts of Nevada and California. It is basically the Colorado River Basin region that is experiencing the low output. Generation for the summer of 2026 was about 28% below the 10-year average for the region.







     As explained below, the low water levels in Lake Powell and Lake Mead are being addressed by water releases from reservoirs in the Upper Colorado River Basin and other measures, including restrictions in downstream water availability.

“Water elevations at Lake Powell and Lake Mead, which are formed by the Glen Canyon Dam and Hoover Dam, respectively, hit record lows. To be able to generate hydropower at the Glen Canyon Dam, Lake Powell should have an elevation of at least 3,490 feet, also known as the minimum power pool. At the end of September, this elevation reached 3,518 feet, less than 1% above minimum power pool. The Hoover Dam requires an elevation of at least 950 feet at Lake Mead, which by the end of September reached 1,038 feet, 9% higher than minimum power pool. The U.S. Bureau of Reclamation manages most dams across the Colorado River Basin. Seven states (Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah, and Wyoming) depend on the river for hydropower generation and for other water supply needs. To mitigate the risk of Lake Powell’s water elevation falling below the minimum power pool, water was released from Flaming Gorge, a reservoir located in the Upper Colorado River Basin. Additionally, water releases from Lake Powell were reduced to maintain an elevation of at least 3,510 feet given the most probable water inflows.”

“However, lower water releases from Lake Powell could also impact water elevation downstream at Lake Mead, in turn affecting hydropower generation at the Hoover Dam. To address this possibility, the Department of the Interior decided to reduce the collective water consumption of California, Arizona, and Nevada by 1.25 million acre-feet each year over the next two years.”

     One possible event that could add precipitation to the region is the current El Niño. These events are strongly associated with higher precipitation. The recent flooding in Arizona last month is likely a part of that increase, and lake levels have been rising accordingly since the summer. Record high rainfall in some areas of Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, and Nevada in late October and early November resulted in significant flash flooding. Thus, those lake levels are also up from their minimums, helping to mitigate the issue.

 

 


References:

 

Hydropower generation in the Southwest fell to record lows this summer. Energy Information Administration, November 13, 2026. Hydropower generation in the Southwest fell to record lows this summer - U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA)

 

Thursday, November 12, 2026

LARCO India Touts Its Turnkey Sewage Treatment Plant Design for Housing Societies: Features Multiple Treatment Stages and Recycling for Non-Potable Use


     Having worked as a sanitarian, or environmental health specialist at the county level, and having seen a housing development on hillsides surrounding a lake and the poorly performing individual septic systems, I can certainly understand why a sewage treatment plant for the whole housing development would be desirable. After going in through a manned gate, it could take 20 minutes to get from one side of the lake to the other due to the steep and narrow roads. One thing that was prevalent there was the smell of sewage, indicating the many failing septic systems. These days, such a development would likely be designed with a communal sewage treatment plant, which would be the most effective sanitation method.

     LARCO India is touting a sewage treatment plant with water-saving, cost-saving, and water recycling features, along with modern redundant treatment methods. LARCO was founded in 1998 and specializes in Wastewater treatment, Sewage Treatment, and Water treatment for municipalities and industry. India is notorious for poor-quality public water and sewage systems like many developing countries. Its public water systems were plagued by extensive leaks, according to a book I read about water in the 2010s. LARCO is located in the state of Maharashtra, India, where wastewater and sewage pollution are environmental concerns. They offer turnkey sewage treatment plant solutions with modular components.

     LARCO’s sewage treatment plant design for housing societies features six stages of operation: 1) Preliminary Treatment, which captures large debris and grit that could harm equipment; 2) Primary Treatment, which involves slow settling of particles into a settling tank; 3) Biological Treatment, which involves the deployment of microbes to break down matter via advanced technologies such as a Moving Bed Biofilm Reactor (MBBR), a Sequential Batch Reactor (SBR), and an Activated Sludge Process (ASP). These result in a reduction of Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD) and Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD), a primary goal of sewage treatment; 4) Secondary Clarification involves separating treated water and biological sludge, the latter of which is disposed of safely; 5) Tertiary Treatment utilizes pressure sand filters, activated carbon filters, UV, or chlorination to remove remaining impurities and pathogens; and 6) Water Reuse, for non-potable uses such as flushing, gardening, and cleaning.

     They also list six benefits of sewage treatment plants: water conservation, lower water bills, environmental protection, regulatory compliance, improved hygiene, and sustainable living.

“A Sewage Treatment Plant for Housing Society is no longer a luxury—it is an essential infrastructure for modern residential developments. By treating and reusing wastewater, housing societies can reduce water consumption, lower operational costs, protect the environment, and comply with pollution control regulations.”

  




References:

 

Sewage Treatment Plant for Housing Society: Benefits, Working & Water Reuse. LARCO India. Blog. Sewage Treatment Plant for Housing Society by LARCO India

Metascience: Can It Spur More Innovation and Discoveries by Making Funding More Efficient? NSF and NIH Propose New Offices Featuring Metascience


What is Metascience?

     Casrai provides a definition of Metascience:

“The empirical, quantitative study of science itself: applying research methods to research methods, reporting practices, evaluation systems, and incentive structures, in order to describe how research is actually conducted and to test interventions that make it more reliable and efficient. Something counts as metascience when its object of study is the research process across a field — study design, statistical power, reporting completeness, peer review, replication rates, or how funding and career incentives shape researcher behavior — rather than a first-order scientific question within a specific discipline. Also called meta-research or, informally, "the science of science."

     David Peterson, a professor of sociology at Purdue University, defines it roughly and simply as “the practice applying scientific scrutiny to the work of science.”

     While I am quite familiar with the study of science itself and the scientific method from thinkers like Thomas Kuhn and Karl Popper, and I have come across many “meta-studies” or “meta-analyses” that look at many different studies simultaneously and compare them, I have not really come across the term ‘metascience’ before. Perhaps I am just late to the game. In any case, ‘meta-studies’ are defined by Microsoft Copilot AI as follows:

“Metastudies” most commonly refers to meta‑analysis—an evidence‑synthesis method that statistically combines results from multiple independent studies to produce a single, more powerful estimate of effect size. It can also refer to broader “meta‑studies” in metatheory, which analyze methods, theories, and knowledge systems themselves.”

 

Metascience for Innovation: Pros and Cons

     Apparently, metascience is being explored for its potential ability to spur innovation. One might see it as a statistical study of a scientific subject, which may reveal things like where most research dollars go or the feasibility of different theories and how much effort and resources are going to each theory.  

     The Aventine Research Institute notes in a recent article entitled ‘Can Metascience Supercharge Scientific Discovery?’ that the National Science Foundation (NSF) and the National Institutes of Health (NIH) recently formed offices within their domains devoted to metascience.

“On September 10, the National Science Foundation (NSF) proposed the creation of a new Office of Metascience. Part of a larger effort to double the impact of each federal dollar spent on science by 2036, the new office is designed to help the agency become a “self-improving institution” that “tries new approaches” and “measures their effects.” The National Institutes of Health (NIH) is creating a new division, too — the Office of Research Economics, Planning, and Analysis — to carry out similar work.”

     Thus, their goal is to make scientific research more efficient. It is my own opinion that while the goal may be noble, it could backfire if the focus becomes too much about research efficiency and less about the research itself. Research takes time and requires failure, or at least ruling out what doesn’t work. It is less amenable to becoming efficient because it is overly inclusive, especially in the beginning, and rigor takes time and resources. Prioritizing is, of course, a priority. (See what I did there - is that a meta-statement?) Nobody wants to waste time, money, and other resources on ideas that have little merit or on ones that are not likely to have much of an effect on society. Thus, having people who work exclusively in prioritizing and weeding out less impactful research may be a good idea.

     The article notes that the UK established a metascience unit in 2024, Ireland and Japan are doing similarly, and that “moonshot factories” such as NSF’s X-Labs initiative and the UK government’s Advanced Research and Invention Agency can be seen as offshoots of metascience.

     Interestingly, the article notes that scientific discoveries have been dropping for years and now require more researchers to manifest.  

“…our ability to generate scientific breakthroughs has declined dramatically. Sustaining the rate of improvement in computer chip advances now requires 18 times as many semiconductor researchers as it did in the 1970s, for example. The number of new drugs approved per billion dollars spent on R&D has halved roughly every nine years since 1950.”

“Metascience is meant to be corrective. It’s about “how [we can] be more effective, more innovative, drive the pace of scientific progress more quickly,” said Stuart Buck, a longtime supporter of metascience who runs the Good Science Project, a nonprofit think tank with the stated mission of improving the funding and practice of science.”

     The article does mention that there are risks to this approach. It’s untested, especially at scale. It may take years or decades to know if it has been worthwhile. They emphasize that success will be hard to measure. However, they also note some measurable improvements. The UK’s Metascience Unit did an experiment where evaluating and peer-reviewing grant applications was undertaken by more researchers, including those applying for grants, rather than a small panel of experts. This resulted in the measurable success of reducing the decision-making time for grant approval or non-approval by three months. It really is hard to measure in the sense that when one research path is chosen over another, it is simply hard to know whether the other one would have yielded better and more useful results. Another issue is that success at a small scale does not mean success when scaled up. Scaling can kill projects as new technical challenges and expenses arise. Another issue is that different sciences have much different standards.

“Standards of evidence, standards for justification, data collection, replication — everything differs widely from field to field,” said Peterson.

     The article also notes some of the history and recent events in metascience. They note that metascience began in the 1930s or possibly earlier. The replication crisis of the 2010s in the field of psychology was blamed on results that were not reproducible due to small sample sizes and the urge to publish, especially to publish surprising results. This led to calls for better apportionment of research dollars. They also cite a 2019 article in The Atlantic by CEO Patrick Collison and economist Tyler Cowen entitled: ‘We Need a New Science of Progress’ as being very influential.

     Finally, the article asks whether metascience is being used as a Trojan horse for budget cuts or whether it is being used for needed disruption and reform of the processes. Stuart Buck, a supporter of metascience who runs the Good Science Project, a nonprofit think tank with the stated mission of improving the funding and practice of science, notes:

“There are a few people who are influential and whose agenda is just cutting science,” he said, but there are others in the administration who he believes have a “good faith intent to improve science.” His hope, he added, is that “the folks with that view can prevail in the end.”

     Collison and Cowen’s article in The Atlantic suggests that scientific research is a major engine for progress. They cite progress-minded 19th-century reformers who shaped some of the best research universities in the U.S., including MIT, Caltech, Johns Hopkins, Harvard, Stanford, and the University of Chicago. They argue that it could be beneficial to study progress itself. They also cite hubs for R&D like Silicon Valley in software and Switzerland’s Basel region in life sciences. They call these cultural ecosystems that foster research. The article covers optimizing talent and training and cultivating the most effective management practices. They call for more investment and research funding and note examples where it has led to innovation and discoveries. Thus, the current version of the Trump administration’s gold standard science push, which includes attention to metascience, while at the same time gutting research funding, does not seem to accord with their ideas. Collison and Cowen make the case for progress resulting from science applied to human well-being and their goal of establishing progress studies. Before this article from 2019, there was and is HumanProgress.org, which is associated with the libertarian-oriented Cato Institute. They have featured in my blog posts several times. They post articles, data, and ideas about human progress.

     The 2010s were a pivotal time for metascience. The replication crisis called for better oversight and methods. Journals began to publish more meta-research. In 2015, a meta-research conference was held for the first time. According to Wikipedia:

“On 8 July 2025, an editorial published in Nature announced the birth of the Metascience Alliance, a coalition of more than 25 funders, academic groups, companies, and other institutions that pursue metascience: the use of scientific methods to understand and improve science itself. The initiative was attended in London by more than 830 participants from around 65 countries. The editorial calls upon metascientists not to limit themselves to studies within academia, but to address the broader social needs, to communicate scientific uncertainty effectively, and rebuild public trust in science.”

     I think that metascience is both the study and management of science and research.      

     Luke Fehilym in an article for The Irish Times, suggests that metascience is resulting in better research outcomes through better management of funding and grants.

      Berna Devezer, a Professor of Marketing at the University of Idaho and practitioner of metascience, wrote an article in The Scientist that strongly criticizes the politicization of metascience, which she thinks is more likely with metascience units and offices, like the NSF and NIH plan to do. Michael Kratsios. Director of the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy put out a big report in July 2026 entitled Science: A New Golden Age, which has both good and bad recommendations in my opinion. It recommends more private sector R&D, which is good. However, private sector R&D is already ample. It is public or government R&D that is good for getting things off the ground, taking on the more difficult, riskier early stages of R&D. “Unleashing innovation” is a goal of the report but it is hard to see that happening when budgets are reduced by a half to two-thirds. It covers the replication crisis, grantmaking, funding, publishing, bureaucracy, institutions, and accountability. I may read and review the report later, now having just scanned a few parts. I will say that the report itself is politicized, with sections where Trump and his team strongly criticize the Biden approach to science. There is a chapter entitled Securing U.S. Dominance in Critical and Emerging Technologies, which I think both parties would support, although the Dems likely won’t keep the word ‘dominance’ that the Trump administration uses ubiquitously. One part I liked is a short section on restoring permissionless innovation, having read and considered Adam Therier’s book and writing on the subject. Below is a snippet from the report:

“Restore Permissionless Innovation: American regulators have grown skilled at weighing the risks of action, but blind to the costs of inaction. Developing good rules require real-world evidence, and building that evidence base only comes from letting innovators prototype and experiment.”

     I also agree with the idea of strengthening public-private partnerships, which is a bipartisan goal. I believe.

     The report also talks about gold standard science. What does that really mean? Devezer tears down the whole idea in her article in The Scientist, noting that adopting the gold standard for financial systems turned out to be wholly inadequate and likely contributed strongly to the Great Depression. That idea has long been abandoned and is widely seen as a failed idea among economists. She says that when recommendations become standards, science fails. The heart of her takedown of the idea is reproduced below:

“First, imposing externally fixed standards on scientific fields without taking the specific needs, aims, and constraints of the fields into account is unlikely to engender progress. Second, systemic, institutional commitment to such external standards will render scientific communities rigid and unable to correct course or adjust to emergent crises. Failing to find the right standards is not my major concern. Top-down imposition of any rigidly held standard would suffice to disrupt the scientific process and derail progress.”

 

“Let me be blunt: There are no gold standards in science and there have never been. This should not come as a surprise to working scientists, or to anyone familiar with the history and philosophy of science. One of the defining characteristics of science is that it keeps challenging its own standards and redefining what it means to practice science at a given moment, in a given field. As philosopher of science Paul Feyerabend captures in a provocative slogan, “anything goes,” scientific progress happens when rigid rules are actively broken and multiple, incompatible theories are allowed to coexist and challenge one another simultaneously.”

     She does think that it is good that the government is interested in metascience but argues that funding is essential and that taking funding away, as the administration has done, undermines the whole process.

“To prioritize our understanding of science as a complex system, NSF should fund both interdisciplinary and discipline-specific metascience as independent research. To advance scientific understanding and to provide solid grounding for applied research, it should also fund basic and theoretical research. There are no gold standards in science. There are, however, scientific communities who do the hard work, day in day out, and what they need is support to build edifices.”

     Jen Gold, who worked on the development of the UK’s metascience unit, wrote in an article for Nature that she thinks they have been successful with some funding reforms and with the mentioned distributed peer review process, which led to much faster grant evaluations. They also implemented a process of removing what they call non-competitive grant applications. She recommends small teams as more effective than larger ones. That is the last recommendation I got from the article before the paywall hit.

     An editorial published a couple of days ago in Nature argues, as its title exemplifies, that “metascience should be a source of evidence, not a means of control.” The article warns against the misuse of metascience and notes that now there is a much larger pool of researchers due to the expansion of universities and the globalization of science.




“Funding agencies need to change how they work to adapt as the world changes. That includes addressing the problem of falling success rates resulting from the greater demand for grants.”

“By far the best way for policymakers to use metascience to inform funding decisions is for them to work with researchers to create and implement tools designed to measure quality and competitiveness, and — as in science itself — to learn from experimentation and experience.”

     Metascience can be quite useful, I believe, but scientists will still need the slack to perfect their ideas. I used to call this “tinker time,” or time to tinker around with ideas and test them and come up with better ideas. I think that holding scientists to higher efficiency standards will backfire. I also think that high levels of funding are necessary for both the public and private sectors. Skimping on R&D simply offers no advantages. Funding can be cut elsewhere. Funding science is too important. Nonetheless, metascience can cut some waste and weed out some of the less plausible and less potentially impactful research going on.  


References:

 

Can Metascience Supercharge Scientific Discovery? Aventine Research Institute. October 1, 2026. Can Metascience Supercharge Scientific Discovery?

Metascience. Casrai. (Dictionary). Metascience - Definition — CASRAI

Metascience. Wikipedia. Metascience - Wikipedia

I built the UK government’s metascience unit — here’s what countries need to know: To find evidence-backed ways to improve grant-funding processes, metascientists need freedom and money to experiment, as well as leaders who are willing to make change. Jen Gold. Nature. October 30, 2026. I built the UK government’s metascience unit — here’s what countries need to know | Nature

Holding Science to a Gold Standard Will Hold It Back: A metascientist pushes back against the unified and idealized vision of science embodied in NSF’s new Office of Metascience. Opinion. Berna Devezer, PhD. The Scientist. October 29, 2026. Holding Science to a Gold Standard Will Hold It Back | The Scientist

Rise of metascience: Turning science on itself: Focus on the ‘science of science’ is ensuring better research outcomes. Luke Fehily. The Irish Times.  October 17, 2024. Rise of metascience: Turning science on itself – The Irish Times

We Need a New Science of Progress: Humanity needs to get better at knowing how to get better. Patrick Collison and Tyler Cowen. The Atlantic. July 30, 2019. We Need a New Science of Progress - The Atlantic

Science: A New Golden Age. A REPORT TO THE PRESIDENT BY MICHAEL KRATSIOS, DIRECTOR OF THE WHITE HOUSE OFFICE OF SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY POLICY. JULY 2026. Science-A-New-Golden-Age.pdf

Metascience should be a source of evidence, not a means of control: The field has captured the interest of politicians. There are positives — but governments must not misuse the data. Editorial. Nature 659, 272. November 10, 2026. Metascience should be a source of evidence, not a means of control | Nature

 

     This report explores trends and strategies for dealing with power demand and expanding industrialization. The authors refer to the “...