The process of brickmaking in Bangladesh involves stacking bricks and burning pulverized coal in between stacks of bricks. A new study shows that how those bricks are stacked and how the coal is placed can result in significant air pollution emissions reduction. Brick kiln pollution in South Asia is a major source of pollution, and efforts to regulate the industry have largely failed in the past in Bangladesh. According to the Stanford Report, the trials convinced regulators in Bangladesh that the new tweaks will work.
“The randomized controlled trial tested an intervention involving simple, low-cost operational changes, such as continuous fuel feeding and more efficient brick stacking. The approach reduced coal use by 23% and carbon dioxide emissions by about 20%, while improving brick quality and reducing owner costs. The intervention's success led initially skeptical Bangladesh government officials to encourage rolling out the intervention nationwide.”
Brick making in Bangladesh is
considered to be an informal industry in a low-income developing country.
Regulation of informal industries in low-income countries has a long record of
failure. However, the improvements in cost reduction and pollution reduction in
this case suggest that the practices should become widely adopted. It was also
noted that exploitative labor practices, such as child labor, are sometimes
used in informal industries, including brick making, and that those who make
brick by this method also face significant pollution exposure. Brick making in
Bangladesh, where 27 billion bricks are produced annually, and in South Asia as
a whole, is a big industry. However, in Bangladesh, it accounts for 17% of CO₂
emissions and 11% of PM2.5 emissions annually.
Researchers at the Boston
School of Public Health, Stanford University, icddr,b, Greentech Knowledge
Solutions, and the Bangladesh University of Engineering and Technology
developed the new methods. Results of the randomized controlled trials:
“…showed that brick kiln owners in Bangladesh are willing
and able to implement cleaner and more efficient business practices within
their operations—without legal enforcement—if they receive the proper training
and support, and if those changes are aligned with their profit motives.”
The study showed that
energy-efficient changes to the production process, such as streamlining brick
stacking and using powered biomass fuel, lead to more complete fuel combustion
and a reduction of heat loss in the kilns. This is a success story as the
following statement from Boston University School of Public Health shows’
“The study found that 65 percent of the brick kiln
owners adopted these changes, which led to a 23-percent reduction in
energy use. The changes substantially improved air quality, contributing to
20-percent reductions in CO₂ and PM2.5 emissions. This intervention also
brought substantial savings in coal expenditures and higher-quality bricks.
Notably, the researchers estimated that the social benefits due CO2 reductions
from the intervention outweighed costs by a factor of 65 to 1 and that the CO2
reductions were achieved at the low cost of $2.85/ton. When the team returned
to participating brick kilns the next year, they found adoption of the improved
practices had not only sustained but increased.”
“Our findings demonstrate that brick kiln owners are
willing to embrace simple changes that protect human and environmental health
when they have the knowledge and training, and those changes deliver tangible
economic gain.”
Current regulations ban the
use of firewood for brick making and have distance requirements from schools
and health facilities. However, enforcement of these rules is often lacking.
“An important area for future research is identifying
strategies to improve work conditions that are aligned with kiln owners’ profit
motives and may be implemented within a weak regulatory state.”
“The researchers’ energy-efficient intervention may be
scalable across South Asia, such as in India and Nepal, where brick
manufacturing practices are similar—and possibly across other industries.
Future research will consider how to best scale the intervention, as well as
develop the next generation of efficiency improvements for the brick industry.”
A 2024 pilot study in Energy
Research & Social Science noted:
“Traditional kilns—in particular fixed chimney kilns—are
highly inefficient. A zigzag kiln, which represents a modest change over the
fixed-chimney kiln and is more energy efficient, is still traditional and
informal. An existing fixed-chimney kiln can be retrofitted into zigzag kiln by
making some modifications to the kiln structure, using a fan, and changing how
bricks are stacked inside the kiln. When constructed and operated properly, a
zigzag kiln enables more complete combustion of fuel and more uniform heat
distribution in the kiln, which reduces emissions but also increases the
profitability of a kiln through reduced fuel costs and increased production of
high-quality bricks. Because zigzag kilns are theoretically more energy
efficient and less polluting, they are classified as “environmentally friendly”
by the GoB. But when zigzag kilns are constructed or operated incorrectly, as
the majority in Bangladesh are, they may be just as polluting as fixed-chimney
kilns. Consequently, the traditional brick industry remains a major source of
greenhouse gas emissions and air pollution.”
The Editor’s summary,
abstract, and conclusions from the new paper in Science are shown below. This is
a public health success story that has the potential to be repeated as
technological advancements to increase efficiency and reduce emissions are
introduced to informal industries around the world.
References:
Research
guides Bangladesh toward cleaner brick production. Stanford Report. Stanford
University. May 8. 2025. Research guides Bangladesh toward
cleaner brick production | Stanford Report
Researchers
Develop Practical Solution to Reduce Emissions and Improve Air Quality from
Brick Manufacturing in Bangladesh. Bangladesh University and Stanford School of
Public Health. May 8, 2025. Researchers Develop Practical
Solution to Reduce Emissions and Improve Air Quality from Brick Manufacturing
in Bangladesh | SPH
Reducing
emissions and air pollution from informal brick kilns: Evidence from Bangladesh.
Nina Brooks, Debashish Biswas, Sameer Maithel, Grant Miller, Aprajit Mahajan,
M. Rofi Uddin, Shoeb Ahmed, Moogdho Mahzab, Mahbubur Rahman, and Stephen P.
Luby. Science. 8 May 2025. Vol 388, Issue 6747. Reducing emissions and air pollution
from informal brick kilns: Evidence from Bangladesh | Science
Building
blocks of change: The energy, health, and climate co-benefits of more efficient
brickmaking in Bangladesh. Nina Brooks, Debashish Biswas, Sameer Maithel, Sonal
Kumar, Mohammad Rofi Uddin, Shoeb Ahmed, Moogdho Mahzab, Grant Miller, Mahbubur
Rahman, and Stephen P. Luby. Energy Research & Social Science. Volume 117,
November 2024, 103738. Building
blocks of change: The energy, health, and climate co-benefits of more efficient
brickmaking in Bangladesh - ScienceDirect
No comments:
Post a Comment