Blog Archive

Wednesday, November 13, 2024

Peatland Management: Carbon Uptake, Methane Emissions, Drinking Water Reservoirs, Drainage Issues, and Uses


     According to Wikipedia:

Peat is an accumulation of partially decayed vegetation or organic matter. It is unique to natural areas called peatlands, bogs, mires, moors, or muskegs.”

     Peat is a formative stage in the eventual formation of lignite coal. Peatlands have specific plant communities such as sphagnum moss. Peat is used in horticulture and gardening to help grow plants. By volume, there are about 4 trillion cubic meters of peat in the world. Global peatland ecosystems cover 3.7 million square kilometers (1.4 million square miles). They are considered to be the most efficient carbon sink on the planet. The peatland plants capture CO2 naturally released from the peat, maintaining an equilibrium. According to Wikipedia:

In natural peatlands, the "annual rate of biomass production is greater than the rate of decomposition", but it takes "thousands of years for peatlands to develop the deposits of 1.5 to 2.3 m [4.9 to 7.5 ft], which is the average depth of the boreal [northern] peatlands",[2] which store around 415 gigatonnes (Gt) of carbon (about 46 times 2019 global CO2 emissions).[12] Globally, peat stores up to 550 Gt of carbon, 42% of all soil carbon, which exceeds the carbon stored in all other vegetation types, including the world's forests, although it covers just 3% of the land's surface.”

     Centuries of burning peat for heat and draining peatlands for agriculture has emitted massive amounts of CO2 to the atmosphere. There is a need for peatlands restoration and conservation.

     Peatlands vary with the types of plant material that decompose to make it up. Peat forms in acidic and anaerobic conditions. Most current peatlands formed about 12,000 years ago in high latitudes after the glaciers retreated. They also occur in some tropical and temperate regions. Peat accumulates at a rate of about 1mm per year. Thus, it is not a renewable resource since it regenerates very slowly.

     Peatlands in the form of bogs and other wetlands make up 50-70% of wetlands globally. Peatlands make up 3% of the Earth’s land and freshwater surface. Peatlands contain one-third of the world’s soil carbon and 10% of global freshwater resources. Around 7% of global peatlands have been exploited for agriculture and forestry. A 2024 paper increases that amount considerably:

 

“…at the global scale, ~11–13% of near-pristine peatlands have been lost due to drainage for croplands, forestry, grasslands production (to support livestock grazing and herbage production, or peat extraction.”

 

      The map below from PEATMAP, a GIS shapefile dataset, shows the global distribution of peatlands.

 






     Peat has many uses, past and present. It was once burned for heat. It was also used in medieval metallurgy. In Sweden, it is used to absorb excrement for farm animals kept indoors in winter. Importantly, peatlands are major drinking water sources, 4% of the global total. In the U.K. 43% of the population derives drinking water from peatlands. In Ireland, the total is 68%. Peatlands help with flood mitigation in some areas. Peat is also used in freshwater aquariums. Peat spas and peat baths are utilized traditionally for health in some European countries.

     About half of the northern peatlands are affected by permafrost and make up about 10% of permafrost lands and contain about 10% of permafrost carbon. Dry peat is a good insulator and helps protect permafrost from thawing.

 

 

Peatland Drainage: Increases Atmospheric CO2 but Also Decreases Atmospheric Methane

     When peatlands are drained for agriculture, forestry, or peat extraction the organic matter, previously underwater is exposed to air, and CO2 is released. Pristine undrained peatlands also emit significant amounts of methane as a result of anaerobic decomposition. The net effect of peatland drainage, however, is an increase in total greenhouse gases and global warming potential. According to Wikipedia:

The global CO2 emissions from drained peatlands have increased from 1,058 Mton in 1990 to 1,298 Mton in 2008 (a 20% increase). This increase has particularly taken place in developing countries, of which Indonesia, Malaysia and Papua New Guinea are the fastest-growing top emitters.”

 

Peat Fires

     The totals above do not include emissions from peat fires. Like coal fires, peat fires can burn under low moisture conditions. They can burn below ground and undetected for years. Burning of peatlands to clear land for agriculture such as planting trees for palm oil is a major source of atmospheric CO2 accumulation from places like Indonesia.

It is estimated that in 1997, peat and forest fires in Indonesia released between 0.81 and 2.57 gigatonnes (0.89 and 2.83 billion short tons; 0.80 and 2.53 billion long tons) of carbon; equivalent to 13–40 percent of the amount released by global fossil fuel burning, and greater than the carbon uptake of the world's biosphere. These fires may be responsible for the acceleration in the increase in carbon dioxide levels since 1998.[70][71] More than 100 peat fires in Kalimantan and East Sumatra have continued to burn since 1997; each year, these peat fires ignite new forest fires above the ground.”

     Peat fires have been problematic in Canada and the Florida Everglades during droughts and in Russia during summer heatwaves. Peatland CO2 emissions, including peat fire emissions, are discussed below.

“…at least 4,000 Mton/CO2-eq./yr for south-east Asia). With 174 Mton/CO2-eq./yr, the EU is after Indonesia (500 Mton) and before Russia (161 Mton), the world's second-largest emitter of drainage-related peatland CO2 (excl. extracted peat and fires). Total CO2 emissions from the worldwide 500,000 km2 of degraded peatland may exceed 2.0 Gtons (including emissions from peat fires), which is almost 6% of all global carbon emissions.”

 

      Thus, peatland management, restoration, extinguishing, and preventing peat fires can have a major effect in reducing global carbon emissions. 

 

 

Restoring, Rewetting, and Reforesting Peatlands to Improve Carbon Uptake and Quantifying Net Greenhouse Gas Effects

     Peatlands are protected as wetlands. The U.N. Convention on Biological Diversity recognizes peatlands as ecosystems to be preserved and protected. The main method of restoring peatlands is simply blocking drainage channels and allowing natural vegetation to recover. This allows peatlands to be rewetted. A November 2023 paper in Nature Scientific Reports exploring peatland rewetting in Sweden notes:

Drainage for forestry has created ~ 1 million km of artificial waterways in Sweden, making it one of the largest human-induced environmental disturbances in the country. These extensive modifications of both peatland and mineral soil dominated landscapes still carry largely unknown, but potentially enormous environmental legacy effects

     Since ditching is commonly used to drain peatlands, rewetting them involves ditch management. Blocking off is the main method. Ditch cleaning involves removing the sediments accumulated in ditches and the increased vegetation along the ditch. This is done in forestry to increase the survival rate of newly planted seedlings. It has been shown to have some negative consequences since sediment and nutrients increase downstream. Its greenhouse gas balance is also not well known. Finland, Russia, and Sweden have the most peatland drained for forestry in the world. Much of it was drained in the first half of the 1900s. Peatland rewetting still needs more studies to quantify its effects better. This is especially true since rewetting increases methane emissions as well as reducing CO2 emissions. The effects of rewetting can vary considerably by area. The researchers in Sweden compared cleaned, left-alone, and filled ditches in consideration of the best way to manage those 1 million km of ditches. Ditch cleaning also affects water quality and its effect on sediment, nutrient, and metal loads can be considerable.

While ditch cleaning in general seems to have had a mitigating influence on the negative effects of the clear-cut for most variables, the 700% increase in sediment load is potentially detrimental to downstream fish habitats and spawning grounds.”

Continued monitoring will be necessary to provide a more solid base for future management decisions, and in the meantime, these management decisions should be made more cautiously and carefully given the little published information we have on their outcomes in a Swedish context.”






     Studies also show that some effects of rewetting and restoring will take years to accurately evaluate and other factors may prevent drained peatlands from returning fully to their previous ecological state.

     A study published in October 2024 in Nature Communications Earth & Environment explored the CO2 and methane emissions of these drainage ditches. The authors found that ditch methane emissions result in retaining about 12% of the emissions of the undrained peatlands while making up 3.1-4.4% of the peatland area. Thus, the ditch emissions are 3-4 times greater than area alone would account for.

“{The authors} conducted a global meta-analysis by compiling annual methane emissions from paired near-pristine peatlands and terrestrial portion of drained peatlands and ditches to address this issue. Results showed that ditches occupy approximately 3.8 (95% confidence interval: 3.1~4.4)% of all drained peatlands. Ditches emit 695 (511~898) kg ha−1 yr−1 methane overall, with the highest emissions observed in (sub)tropics. Globally, ditch emissions offset approximately 12 (10~14)% for reductions in methane emissions from peatland drainage. Our findings demonstrate the importance of including ditch methane emissions to quantify emission factors for regional to global peatlands affected by drainage.”

 

Data from the paper are shown below.







 

References:

 

Peat. Wikipedia. Peat - Wikipedia

Ditch emissions partially offset global reductions in methane emissions from peatland drainage. Dezhao Gan, Zelong Zhang, Huinan Li, Dongsheng Yu, Zheng Li, Ruijun Long, Shuli Niu, Hongchao Zuo, Xianhong Meng, Jinsong Wang & Lei Ma. Nature Communications Earth & Environment volume 5, Article number: 640 (October 29, 2024). Ditch emissions partially offset global reductions in methane emissions from peatland drainage | Communications Earth & Environment

Potential of continuous cover forestry on drained peatlands to increase the carbon sink in Finland. Aleksi Lehtonen, Kyle Eyvindson, Kari Härkönen, Kersti Leppä, Aura Salmivaara, Mikko Peltoniemi, Olli Salminen, Sakari Sarkkola, Samuli Launiainen, Paavo Ojanen, Minna Räty & Raisa Mäkipää .Scientific Reports volume 13, Article number: 15510 (2023). Potential of continuous cover forestry on drained peatlands to increase the carbon sink in Finland | Scientific Reports

Consequences of rewetting and ditch cleaning on hydrology, water quality and greenhouse gas balance in a drained northern landscape. Hjalmar Laudon, Virginia Mosquera, Karin Eklöf, Järvi Järveoja, Shirin Karimi, Alisa Krasnova, Matthias Peichl, Alexander Pinkwart, Cheuk Hei Marcus Tong, Marcus B Wallin, Alberto Zannella & Eliza Maher Hasselquist. Scientific Reports volume 13, Article number: 20218 (2023). Consequences of rewetting and ditch cleaning on hydrology, water quality and greenhouse gas balance in a drained northern landscape | Scientific Reports

 

 

No comments:

Post a Comment

     The SCORE Consortium is a group of U.S. businesses involved in the domestic extraction of critical minerals and the development of su...

Index of Posts (Linked)