I am fortunate to live in a country where any citizen can openly criticize the government or its actions. Places and situations where one cannot do that include both political and religious prohibitions that cross over into human rights denial. Basic human rights should be emphasized as paramount, as trumping other concerns. Countries that are democracies offer, by far, the best protections of human rights.
There are obvious situations where
rights to criticize governments have been revoked and criminalized. Russia did
it after it invaded Ukraine, handing out prison terms, some lengthy, for those
who criticize the Kremlin’s war. Iran imprisons those who criticize its
government and sometimes executes political prisoners as treasonous
collaborators with its enemies in obviously sham trials. People tend to leave
those countries if they can, becoming defectors. They often don’t mind that
since they would prefer detractors not to live among them. North Korea goes so
far as to threaten the families of those who may be captured fighting against
Ukraine or to execute people, even children, simply for watching South Korean
TV shows or movies. China imprisons people for speaking out against the
communist party. Authoritarians control behavior with harsh threats. That is
their MO. These four countries have totalitarian governments. Iran may change
its president and parliament members, but its government is still quite
totalitarian. Other countries can also be seen as totalitarian. These include
the Gulf State monarchies and other countries that limit and suppress
opposition parties. Islamic countries, in general, have limited freedom of
speech, some more or less than others. Marxist Latin American countries have
been associated with human rights abuses. These include Venezuela, Cuba,
Bolivia, and Nicaragua, although Bolivia now has a better, non-socialist
government.
Oddly, in France and some other
countries in Europe, where recent protests have been intense, sometimes
involving violence, and with abundant vandalism and arson, it is the Islamists
and far-left Marxists who have been a feature of the protests, though many
others are involved as well. In essence, they are exercising their rights as
citizens of democratic countries. Their rights do not extend to the right to
commit crimes. The far-left parties are the parties that use protest as a means
most often in democratic countries. They are also the protestors most likely to
become violent. They are basically abusing the freedom of speech by taking it
too far and mixing it with destructive and sometimes violent actions. It’s odd
that Islamists would boldly protest against democratic governments when the
governments of the countries they came from would not allow it at all. While it
is fine that they protest if they are non-violent, they should perhaps be
content to live in a country that has basic human rights.
In Gaza there was never such
freedom to criticize the government, or rather Hamas. I read a story recently
that journalists in Gaza would routinely suppress stories where some citizens
were speaking out against Hamas policies out of fear of reprisal. That
certainly indicates no freedom of the press in a place where there is also no
real freedom of speech. Any anti-Hamas groups that appeared were routinely
killed by Hamas. It should not be forgotten that Gaza’s government is also a
widely recognized terrorist organization that to this day refuses to disarm,
still seeks to import weapons and re-militarize, and is still recruiting
members, despite the literal destruction of much of their country. Fanatics
have strong beliefs and dedication. They are aided by the propaganda spewed by
anti-Zionists around the world in many ways. We hear much about the suffering
of the Palestinian people, the same people who celebrated 911, who thrashed the
Israeli captives as they were brought to Gaza in October 2023, and many who
kept those people confined in miserable conditions where they were tortured
physically and psychologically. Of course, there are Palestinian people in Gaza
who really want no part of Hamas. However, even those people are trapped out of
fear of criticizing them and have been indoctrinated by Hamas propaganda,
including from the UN schools that help to spread it. That the UN was heavily
infiltrated by the world’s best-known terrorist organization is a stain on the
UN’s credibility. Of course, it is not wrong to argue that Israel has been too
heavy-handed and has killed many more civilians than necessary despite the
extensive human shielding.
The Right to Criticize Religion: Islam is the Main Problem
Religious blasphemy laws in some
Islamic countries are long outdated and suppressive of basic human rights.
Threatening to execute someone or actually doing it, which has happened, for
crimes such as insulting the prophet is a human rights issue. Saudi Arabia
recently threatened to execute a worker from Sri Lanka for the crime of
insulting the Prophet. Egypt has done the same with a man who converted from
Islam to Christianity. The fiancée of the man accused alleged that at least 180
other Christians are being held by the authorities on similarly dubious
charges. The accusers often cite Sharia Law as the basis for the penalties.
Sharia Law, which is based on Medieval interpretations of Islamic Law, is
simply incompatible with basic human rights. The draconian laws against women
and minorities in Pakistan and especially Afghanistan under Taliban rule are
more examples of obvious human rights abuses. These countries need to get the
fuck out of the Middle Ages and treat people fairly.
Israel has been hailed as the only
democracy in the Middle East. There, one can criticize both the government and
the religions. I just heard on the radio yesterday an editor of the
left-leaning Israeli media organization Haaretz strongly criticize the
Netanyahu government. One can also criticize the religion-based views of the
highly religious far-right Jews. Of course, Israel also has millions of Sunni
Arabs, and they have representatives in the Israeli government in proportion to
their share of the population. The governments of Lebanon and Iraq have
power-sharing features where different religious sects, which include
Christianity in Lebanon, are automatically represented. Of course, these are
not democracies but have some features of democracies. One time in the 2000s, I
was at an international festival in a university town and was looking at the
flags of all the countries and by chance met the only two Afghan students at
the university. They seemed to be nice guys and were proud to find their flag represented.
We had a short discussion about religious freedom and though their words were
guarded, they sort of conceded that people should be free to practice any
religion they chose to practice, though they seemed a bit put off by my
inquiries.
There are other conflicts in the
world where those who practice Islam are oppressed by those who don’t, such as
the poor treatment of the Rohingya minority in Myanmar by the military
government.
There are also places where there
is no freedom for any religion, such as in communist China, where Sinicization
is what is offered to replace religion. According to an article in the New York
Post:
“President Xi Jinping euphemistically defines
Sinicization as “adapting religion to socialism with Chinese characteristics.”
In practice it means pastors must ban all minors under 18 years old from
church, center sermons on Xi Jinping’s Thought, and spy on their congregations,
among many other demands and restrictions.”
Protestant Christianity, the
biggest religious movement in China, is the latest target of Sinicization.
China also suppresses the religions of ethnic minorities such as the Uyghur
Muslims and the Tibetan Buddhists, among others. China’s recently passed ethnic
unity law is another farce with very thinly veiled racism as a feature.
“It is using lawfare in kangaroo courts against the
Christians, not the brutal tactics that it applies to crush the Tibetan
Buddhists, Uyghur Muslims, or Falun Gong practitioners. It is persecution
nonetheless.”
In conclusion, freedom of speech,
freedom of the press, and freedom of religion all preserve the right to
criticize any government or religion, and those rights are fundamental to a
modern world that is fair, impartial, and civilized.
References:
They
had him crucified: Christian convert faces torture, execution in Egypt for
leaving Islam. Danielle Greyman-Kennard. The Jerusalem Times. November 9, 2026.
They
had him crucified: Christian convert faces torture, execution in Egypt for
leaving Islam
Saudi
Arabia has sentenced a foreign worker to death over a Facebook post. Why isn’t
there a bigger outcry? The independent. Alisha Rahaman Sarkar. October 7, 2026.
Saudi
Arabia has sentenced a man to death over a Facebook post. Why isn’t there a
bigger outcry? | The Independent
China
unleashes a sweeping crackdown on Christians. Nina Shea. New York Post. November
15, 2026. China
unleashes a sweeping crackdown on Christians
No comments:
Post a Comment