This report explores trends and
strategies for dealing with power demand and expanding industrialization. The
authors refer to the “electro-industrial era,” where “growth and national
security depend on an increasingly interconnected system of electrified
technologies and supply chains.” RMI’s
economic development team partnered with the New Energy Industrial Strategy
(NEIS) Center to develop the framework outlined in this report. The report
emphasizes that “state and local tax credits and project-level investment
incentives play an important role in mobilizing private capital, catalyzing job
and cluster growth, and enabling electricity capacity expansion.”
The authors note that the
technologies powering this electro-industrial era share three features:
efficiency (due to avoiding combustion), scalability, and digitalization
capacity (software upgrades can improve hardware capabilities). As the table
below indicates, there are examples of these, such as the high efficiency of
thermal energy storage, and another one that I think might be cool – digitally
upgradable heat pumps.
Below, they show how clean energy
and electrification technologies have dropped dramatically in price. While that
is impressive, they are still not competitive with fossil fuels, especially
when integration and delivery costs are included. The second graph shows
lithium-ion cost drops and demand along with projections. Those projections
suggest that lithium-ion cost drops are pretty much maxed out.
The graph below shows Mainland
China’s utter dominance in most of these technologies, their supply chains,
components, and resources. That graph alone should give some pause for an
all-in electrification push since China has already shown a willingness to
restrict supplies of critical minerals and components and has implemented
export controls, which would compromise U.S. energy security.
The U.S. has responded by
increasing the development of domestic critical minerals mining and processing
and associated supply chains, but this will take time, likely decades. The
graph below shows U.S. investment towards alleviating the supply chain risks,
with most just beginning in the early 2020s. They also note that the U.S. is
set to capture only a “puny” share of the growing new energy export market
worldwide.
The next graph is interesting. It
shows the projected selected global drivers of electricity demand growth to
2050. These are all existing technologies that will grow in deployment.
The report then delves into
regional electricity demand growth due to subnational policy changes, mainly by
states. They see an abundance of demand growth in the Southeastern region.
However, their graphs are based on capacity additions, which makes them hugely
misleading, as usual.
The flow chart below shows an
idealized scenario where all technology and policy work together to accelerate
project development. It includes faster and more predictable permitting, which
will likely happen if the more Progressive Dems are not able to block BAAJA
permit reform.
The map below is interesting. It
shows a county-level map of projects that could be considered
electro-industrial. They note the emergence of a region where battery projects
are proliferating in the Great Lakes and Midwest, which they are calling a
battery belt; the prevalence of solar, wind, and battery projects in Texas;
semiconductor project development in Arizona’s Maricopa County; and lithium
supply and processing development in Nevada, which hosts the largest U.S.
lithium mine and associated supply chains. They suggest that these clusters
make other projects more likely to be developed in them due to the synergies,
which makes other areas less likely to host them.
Below, they display what they call
a GREASE policy framework for subnational industrial policy. GREASE is an
acronym for “governance, regional targeting, expansive ambition,
accountability, sector strategies, and environmental co-benefits.” They
note four areas where state and local policies can be effective: market
development, private capital mobilization, site readiness, and workforce
development.
The map below shows where economic
benefits will result from favorable state incentives. Here, it can be seen that
the Great Lakes and Southeast regions stand to benefit most from state and
local electro-industrial incentives.
It should be noted that projects
with low profitability or long-term payback of investments often require
significant incentives just to stay above water. Some projects that may be in
the public interest are simply not very profitable or not profitable at all.
Thus, those types of projects are simply not likely to proliferate under any
scenario but may merely add a little bit to satisfying demand. Overcoming
economic barriers through incentives alone is not broadly feasible. I think we
need to be careful, as overbuilding clean energy and clean industry too fast
has the very real risk of raising power costs for consumers, a sensitive issue.
Unfortunately, most of their policy recommendations are based mainly on
increasing incentives and subsidies, something the Trump administration has
gutted. It is likely that, with a new Democratically controlled Congress, many
of these incentives can return, and I agree that they should. Even after they
return, issues with profitability will remain for many technologies.
Most of the following questions
can be answered, in my opinion, by proceeding cautiously and slowly and
avoiding projects with the worst economics. We don’t want to pay high costs for
projects with little economic benefit. Therefore, I don’t think it would be
wise to seek to vastly accelerate the deployment of these technologies before
they are market-ready and at least somewhat competitive at typical incentive
levels.
References:
Subnational
Industrial Strategy in the Electro-Industrial Era: How states and regions can
win durable investment, jobs, and leadership in new energy. Aaron Brickman, Ben
Feshbach, and Hannah Perkins. RMI. September 4, 2026. Subnational Industrial Strategy in
the Electro-Industrial Era - RMI










No comments:
Post a Comment